GBIC vs SFP vs Mini GBIC: What is the difference?

Table of Contents

What is GBIC?
What is SFP?
What is Mini GBIC?
GBIC vs SFP vs Mini GBIC comparison chart
GBIC vs SFP
GBIC vs Mini GBIC
Mini GBIC vs SFP
FAQ
Conclusion

In previous articles, We introduced you to GBIC, Mini GBIC, and SFP basics. However, in practical applications, many network beginners and technicians still need clarification about the difference between GBIC vs SFP vs Mini GBIC.

Although you can find some related articles online, most pieces must be more cohesive and detailed. That is the reason why we made this post. In this post, we will systematically and comprehensively compare those terms, GBIC, SFP, and Mini GBIC, to help you understand the differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each.

Whether you’re a network beginner, administrator, engineer, or someone looking to upgrade your network equipment, this post will provide valuable insights to help you make an informed decision.

So, let’s dive into and explore the differences between GBIC, SFP, and Mini GBIC.

We will explain their definitions before formally comparing GBIC, SFP, and Mini GBIC. For detailed information, you may read our previous articles.

What is GBIC?

GBIC, short for ‘Gigabit Interface Converter’, first launched in 1995 by GBIC MSA INF-8053, is the earliest hot-pluggable form factor in the optical transceiver industry. Initially designed for Fibre Channel and Gigabit Ethernet applications, it also supported 100M and 2.5G data rates. The most common terms include GBIC transceiver, GBIC connector, and GBIC port.

What is SFP?

SFP, short for ‘Small Form-factor Pluggable’, first launched in 2000 by INF-8074, is a hot-pluggable form factor and interface with a smaller size. While inheriting the advantages of GBIC, SFP also provides better port density and more functions, thus Avoiding the disadvantages of GBIC.

They are commonly used in switches, routers, and network interface cards (NICs). The most common terms include SFP module, SFP connector, and SFP port.

What is Mini GBIC?

Mini GBIC is another name for SFP, and it is just a more graphic term. “Mini GBIC” is a more expressive term for SFP as it implies a smaller size and more compact design than the traditional GBIC. Overall, Mini GBIC and SFP are interchangeable terms that refer to the same type of form factor, with “Mini GBIC” being a more descriptive and visual term, while “SFP” is the more commonly used industry term.

Further Reading

GBIC vs SFP vs Mini GBIC, What is the difference?

The table below shows the main differences and similarities between them.

Comparison	GBIC	SFP	Mini GBIC
Size	SFP is smaller than GBIC, around 1/2 of the size of GBIC	GBIC is larger than SFP, around two size of SFP	Same as SFP
Standard	GBIC MSA INF-8053	SFP MSA INF-8074i	Same as SFP
Wavelength	850nm 1310nm 1550nm	850nm 1310nm 1550nm	Same as SFP
Reach	Max 80km	Max 180km	Same as SFP
Fiber Type	MMF, SMF	MMF, SMF	Same as SFP
Connector Type	SC	LC	Same as SFP
Data Rate	Only avalible in 155M, 1.25G	Wide rate avalible in 155M, 622M, 1.25G, 2.5G, 2GFC, 3G,4GFC, 6G	Same as SFP
DOM Support	Yes	Yes	Same as SFP
Operating Temperature	0°C to 70°C (Commercial Grade) -40°C to 85°C (Industrial Grade)	0°C to 70°C (Commercial Grade) -40°C to 85°C (Industrial Grade)	Same as SFP
Compatibility	Yes	Yes	Same as SFP
Weight	~45g	~25g	Same as SFP
Rlease date	Around 1990s, Earlier than SFP	Around 2000s, Later than GBIC	Same as SFP
Price (Optcore)	Higher	Lower	Same as SFP
Pros	NA	Popular and more vendors available Higher port density Short lead time Lower price than GBIC Diversified options for different scenarios	Same as SFP
Cons	Outdated, and very few vendors are available Lower port density Long lead time It is a much higher price than SFP Very few options for different scenarios	NA	Same as SFP
Application	Old networking device	Medern networking device	Same as SFP

Table 1: GBIC vs SFP vs Mini GBIC

GBIC vs. SFP

Now, let us compare the main differences between GBIC and SFP. GBIC and SFP are both hot-swappable, industry-standard form factors for optical transceivers. However, there are several critical differences.

Size and weight: GBIC is larger than SFP. The weight is around equal to 2 SFPs, so it takes up more space on a switch or router. In other words, SFP can save valuable space for networking devices.
Port density: Because of their smaller size, SFP can provide higher port density than GBIC. That means a switch or router with SFP ports can support more ports than one with GBIC ports.
Power consumption: SFPs generally consume less power than GBICs. It is vital to the power-sensitive device.
Data rate: SFPs can support more and higher data transfer rates than GBICs. The standard GBIC only supports 100Mbps, 1.25Gbps, and 2.5Gbps, while SFP also supports 622Mbps, 3Gbps, 4.25Gbps and 6Gbps.
Availability: SFPs are more widely available than GBICs, which are becoming less common in modern networking equipment.
Pricing: in the earlier days, GBICs may have had lower pricing than SFPs. However, with the increasing popularity of SFPs, their pricing has become more comparable. Nowadays, you may have to pay GBIC for two or more times than the same type of SFP.

Overall, SFPs offer advantages over GBICs in size, port density, power consumption, data rate, and pricing. However, GBICs may still be helpful in specific scenarios, such as when compatibility with older equipment is required.

GBIC vs. SFP: When to Choose Which?

Choose GBIC if compatibility with older equipment is required. Otherwise, choose SFP for its size, power consumption, data rate, and pricing advantages.

GBIC vs. Mini GBIC

In the previous section, we learned that Mini GBIC is simply another name for SFP or just a nickname. Therefore, when it comes to the comparison of GBIC vs Mini GBIC, it is essentially the comparison of GBIC vs SFP. So please refer to the above section.

Put simply, the words ‘Mini’ have already been stated in a literal way that they differ in appearance and size. The latter is the smaller version of GBIC. So, GBIC vs. Mini GBIC and GBIC vs SFP are the same question.

Mini GBIC vs. SFP

As previously mentioned, Mini GBIC is just another name for SFP, so there is no difference besides the name itself.

However, some beginners may still feel confused about the difference between Mini GBIC and SFP, as the two terms are used interchangeably. It is important to note that Mini GBIC is just a marketing term used by some vendors to describe the SFP form factor, and it does not refer to a different technology or standard. So, whether you see Mini GBIC or SFP mentioned, they both refer to the same small form-factor pluggable transceiver.

FAQs about GBIC vs. SFP vs. Mini GBIC

Q: Can we connect GBIC with the SFP module?

A: In some cases, connecting a GBIC with an SFP module is possible. However, this requires that the GBIC and SFP have equal data transfer rates, use the same fiber cable, have matching wavelengths, and have enough link budgets. It is crucial to ensure all these requirements are met before connecting them. Besides that, you should use a suitable patch cable to connect the SC and LC interface.

Q: Is there a GBIC to SFP converter adapter?

A: Not sure, but at least we have yet to find it. The possible reason is that although producing the GBIC to SFP adapter is not tricky, Minimal market demand prevented him from showing up.

Final Words

Understanding the differences between GBIC, SFP, and Mini GBIC is crucial when purchasing network equipment. While GBIC was the old form factor, SFP or Mini GBIC offers more advantages and is more widely available and cost-effective. Choose GBIC only if compatibility with older equipment is required.

If you have any related questions or comments, please submit them in the comments section below. We look forward to hearing from you.

Reference:

https://www.snia.org/node/4897

Read more:

Optical Transceiver