We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

The 11 Best Comfortable Flats of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

After testing 29 options, these stylish picks were the best.

A pair of nisolo huarache sandals on a hardwood floor

Real Simple / Alena Kharlamenko

Comfortable flats are a staple in any wardrobe since they can easily be dressed up or down for any occasion. While they aren't the most supportive type of footwear, it is possible to find a pair that maximizes comfort without sacrificing style, especially if you're looking for something more elevated than sneakers or slip-ons.

According to David Abdoo, DPM, a podiatrist at ​​Salinas Valley Foot & Ankle, flats “are not an ideal choice for activities that require extended standing or walking.” (Comfortable sneakers would be a better option.) But, that doesn't mean you should write them off completely. “It's essential to consider your specific needs, such as high arches or flat feet, and the intended use of the footwear,” he says.

To find the most comfortable flats, we tested 29 pairs in real-world conditions. We looked at the quality and materials of each pair and checked out how the soles moved and flexed. We wore the shoes around our homes and throughout our daily routines, noticing how our feet felt and whether the shoes caused pain, blisters, or rubbing.

We also brought in the experts: In addition to Dr. Abdoo, we also spoke with Shital Sharma, DPM, a board-certified podiatrist with Pinewood Family Care Co. Both doctors weighed in on what to look for in a pair of comfortable flats, signs that your flats need replacing, and more.

Best Overall Comfortable Flats

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane

Rothy’s

Our Ratings
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Comfort
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • They felt great on various terrains for thousands of steps per day—and they’re machine-washable.

What Could Be Improved
  • The straps can’t be adjusted.

Rothy’s are known for their comfy, machine-washable shoes and material made from recycled single-use plastic bottles. These lightweight Mary Janes have a durable, flexible sole that supported our feet on pavement, pebbles, and cobblestones. We tested them walking, driving, running errands, and for social events. Overall, we were impressed by how stylish these shoes look, how comfortable they felt in hot and chilly weather, and how versatile they are with everything from leggings to dressy attire. 

We loved that we didn't need to break in the shoes for them to fit well—they felt secure right away and didn’t stretch out over time. The soles were initially a bit slippery but had great traction after we wore them a bit. Our feet felt great after walking up to 10,000 steps daily in these shoes, with no swelling, overheating, blisters, or chafing. 

These shoes were even comfortable to wear during pregnancy with swollen feet, which made us appreciate these flats even more. They stayed in pristine shape throughout two months of regular use and the stain-resistant material resisted any wear and tear. We also thought the new-school ballet flat style was perfectly versatile for day-to-day wear.

These shoes can dress up or down, making them an ideal option for weekend trips (they're incredibly packable) or a capsule wardrobe. They currently come in eight colors, including classics like black and gardenia (white with black piping). There are also more unique color options like lollipop red and pink. We do wish the strap across the top was adjustable, which could help people with narrow feet get a more secure fit. 

Size Range: 5–13 | Material: Recycled plastic | Sole: Not listed

Best Budget Comfortable Flats

Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flat

Frank Mully Women's Round Toe Ballet Flat

Frank Mully

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    4/5
What Stands Out
  • There was no break-in period for these comfortable, versatile shoes.

What Could Be Improved
  • The soles are thin and don’t have much traction.

We didn’t need time to break into these true-to-size flats; they were comfortable immediately. These shoes have a breathable knit upper and a flexible rubber sole that feels great while walking thousands of steps per day. Plus, after two months of regular wear, they still felt comfortable and looked high-quality. We loved pairing these flats with jeans, pants, and skirts—and at such an affordable price, you can even stock up on multiple pairs.

We liked the huge variety of colors and styles, with over 25 options ranging from leopard print to flamingo pink. Some styles seem to have more padding and support than others, which made shopping for them a bit confusing. We also loved how they were easy to wash. After stepping in mud, we washed them on a delicate cycle using cold water and a mild detergent and let them air dry. After cleaning, they looked brand-new. 

Our feet felt supported in these shoes, but the soles felt a bit thin. These shoes aren’t the best for rainy or icy weather, as the lightweight rubber soles were slippery on slick ground. Still, these are stylish, comfortable shoes at a great price point. 

Size Range: 6–12 | Material: Knit | Sole: Rubber

Most Supportive Comfortable Flats

Vionic Caroll Ballet Flat

Amazon Vionic Carroll Ballet Flat

Amazon

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4.5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • These flats have great arch support.

What Could Be Improved
  • The leather material can cause temporary rubbing or blisters while the shoes break in.

These leather ballet flats have a cute crossover design on the toe and are available in tan, navy, and black. We loved the robust arch support and that these shoes have the APMA Seal of Acceptance (from the American Podiatric Medical Association), indicating that the design helps promote good foot health. Based on the fit and quality, we expect these shoes to last several years, making the price point worth it. We wore these shoes for two months and they didn't sustain any scratches or scuffs, which is especially impressive considering the shiny material.

These flats felt like wearing a pair of comfy sneakers. We had no problems going up and down stairs, walking around a trade show, and even helping move furniture on a hot day. We did find that the leather upper may need some breaking in—we experienced some rubbing and blisters after one particularly long day, which can happen the first few times you wear a stiffer shoe.

Size Range: 5–12, medium and wide | Material: Leather | Sole: Thermoplastic rubber

Most Comfortable Ballet Flats

Margaux The Demi Flat

Margaux The Demi Flat

Amazon

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Durability
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • These flats boast a classic style and an incredible size range.

What Could Be Improved
  • They are very expensive.

We found that these shoes needed a day or so to break in, and initially caused some rubbing and hot spots on our ankles and the tops of our feet. After that, we found them incredibly comfortable. The Nappa leather uppers felt soft and malleable, hugging our feet for an overall comfortable fit.

During our initial testing, we noticed that the leather soles were slim and inflexible, which provided some structure and support but also led to some tired arches after 8-hour days walking around New York City. Despite this, our long-term testing revealed that the thin sole is surprisingly sturdy and reliable, so it may be that it just takes some getting used to.

We wore these flats for dinners out, shopping, work, and errands and found that they held up incredibly well over two months. We also appreciated that the soft leather exterior didn't become scratched or scuffed—the shoes still look fresh from the box.

We love the classic design of these shoes and found that they went well with almost any outfit. These ballet flats come in various stylish colors and an incredible size range, from US 3 to US 14 (with medium, narrow, and wide widths available). And the classic bow isn’t just for show—it’s an adjustable cord you can use to tighten or loosen the shoe for a better fit. 

Size Range: 3–14; narrow, medium, and wide | Material: Italian Nappa leather | Sole: Leather

Most Comfortable Mary Janes

Vivaia Margot Mary Jane

VIVAIA Square-Toe Mary Jane (Margot Mary Jane)

Vivaia

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • These lightweight shoes have a fully adjustable instep strap.

What Could Be Improved
  • The fit may not work well for people with wider feet.

These Vivaia flats have a knit upper made from recycled plastic bottles, a deodorizing insole, and a rubber outsole with a slight heel. The square shape provides plenty of toe room, and the material feels light and breathable even in hot weather and rain. Plus, the cushioned insole kept our feet supported and comfortable for hours on end (and stayed just as plush after two months of testing).

During testing, we found that the flexible rubber soles flexed but still provided plenty of support so that we couldn’t feel rocks or uneven terrain while walking. After two months of regular wear, they got a bit dirty—but after a quick spot-cleaning with shoe cleaner and a towel, they looked as good as new.

Our favorite part of these shoes is the instep strap, which is fully adjustable to ensure a good fit over the top of your foot. We were also impressed by how lightweight and flexible these shoes are. We could fold them flat for easy packing, making them great for weekend trips and travels. 

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Knit | Sole: Rubber

Most Comfortable Loafer

Birdies The Starling Flat

Birdies Women's Starling Flats

Birdies

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4.5/5
  • Fit
    4.5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • The quilted, cushioned insole provides superior comfort.

What Could Be Improved
  • The velvet fabric doesn’t hold up well to weather (or pet hair).

These classic loafers have an 8-millimeter heel and a non-slip rubber sole. We loved the quilted, cushioned insole, which made us feel like we were wearing comfortable slippers rather than outdoor shoes. The sturdy footbed kept our feet comfortable for up to eight hours of indoor and outdoor wear. 

We tested a velvet pair, which might not be the best choice for hot weather or precipitation (we also found that pet hair stuck to the fabric, so we needed a lint roller handy). After two months of wear, we noticed that the velvet was scuffed in a few places, though the damage wasn't too obvious. Despite this minor drawback, the flats held up well to our long-term tests and remained comfortable throughout. We even got into the habit of wearing these as house shoes—they're just that comfortable.

Plus, if you want a more durable material, these flats come in other fabric options, including suede, leather, calf hair, raffia, and tapestry, so you can find options for different seasons. 

Size Range: 5–13; medium and wide | Material: Velvet, suede, leather, calf hair, raffia, and tapestry | Sole: Rubber

Most Comfortable Sandal

Margaux The Wrap Sandal

Margaux The Wrap Sandal

Margaux

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4.5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    4.5/5
What Stands Out
  • These sandals have high-quality materials and a stylish look.

What Could Be Improved
  • The price point is higher than most other options on our list.

We loved these stylish wrap sandals as a day-to-night shoe option. In our experience, lace-up straps are usually fiddly or uncomfortable, but these were neither. After we found the most comfortable way to tie the laces (looping them twice around our ankles and securing them with a bow), the shoes stayed secure. Plus, the laces are made from buttery leather that didn't dig into our legs or leave welts. The soles felt thin but weren’t flimsy, and the 5mm of foam padding helped the shoes mold to our feet. They don’t have much traction but are comfortable for wearing to work and out for brunch. 

These shoes are handmade in Spain and come in women’s sizes 3–14, making them a great option for people who wear harder-to-find shoe sizes. The brand recommends avoiding wearing these in the rain and using a leather lotion to keep the shoes supple. 

Size Range: 3–14 (narrow, medium, and wide) | Material: Italian Nappa leather | Sole: Not listed

Most Comfortable Pointed-Toe Flats

Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Ballet Flats

Vivaia Pointed-Toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats

Vivaia

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4.5/5
  • Fit
    4.5/5
  • Quality
    4.5/5
  • Support
    4.5/5
What Stands Out
  • These shoes fit very well on narrow feet.

What Could Be Improved
  • The water-repellent fabric doesn’t stand up to super heavy rain.

These flats come in a range of solid colors and cute prints, including water-repellent fabric in cream or black. The super-flexible sole was comfortable to walk in, and we liked the light arch support and extra cushioning around the toe and heel areas. We found that the heels of these shoes didn’t slip off our narrow feet or gape mid-step.

During two months of testing, we wore these flats multiple times a week and found that they still looked as good as new (we're notoriously rough on shoes, so this was especially impressive). The knit upper didn't stretch or lose shape, which makes us confident that these will fit well for years to come. Once, we packed just this shoe and a sneaker for a trip and were happy to find that they were versatile for many outfits and occasions. We enjoyed these shoes so much that we're considering buying a second pair in another hue.

We also tested these waterproof flats in rainy weather and noticed water beading up on the shoe fabric rather than soaking in. Our feet still got wet in super heavy rain (because the shoe’s low profile allows rain to hit your feet directly), but the fabric lives up to the water-repellent promise. Plus, the textured rubber sole had fantastic traction and didn’t slip on marble, tile, or wet pavement.

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Knit | Sole: Rubber

Best Dressy Comfortable Flats

Naturalizer Samantha d'Orsay Flat

Naturalizer Samantha Half d'Orsay Flat

Nordstrom

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4/5
  • Fit
    4/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    4.5/5
What Stands Out
  • The sides are stretchy, and the sole provides a surprising amount of arch support.

What Could Be Improved
  • There was a break-in period.

These flats have a leather and suede upper, and the contrast of the two fabrics gives the shoes a stylish look. We appreciated the comfortable add-ons, like the padding at the ball of the foot and stretch at the side of the shoe for more flexible movement. Initially, these shoes had a sturdy, solid sole that didn’t bend much, but with time and continued wear, they became more bendable and comfortable. After two months of use, we still feel that these shoes are a reliable, quality pair of flats perfect for warmer months.

We love the shoe's classic shape and color, which makes this pair great for anything from a workday to an outdoor wedding. We also like the low hidden wedge heel, which helps us feel supported while walking. The non-slip outsole provides traction, and the shoes are designed using sustainable materials and packaged in boxes made from 80% recycled paper with soy-based ink. Still, it's worth noting that these shoes took a few hours to break in, and in that time caused some rubbing and blisters on the back of our heels.

Size Range: 4–12; narrow, medium, and wide | Material: Leather | Sole: Not listed

Most Comfortable Flats for Warm Weather

Nisolo Huarache Sandal

Nisolo Women's Huarache Sandal

Nisolo

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    3.5/5
  • Fit
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • These sandals have a high-quality and beautiful design.

What Could Be Improved
  • They aren't the best option for very long walks.

These woven sandals are made from super-soft leather with a flexible rubber sole that provides plenty of support. We particularly liked how the leather uppers moved and breathed with our feet, and thanks to the woven design, our feet got plenty of airflow and never felt overheated or sweaty. We love that they're available in five neutral colors, and demonstrate gorgeous craftsmanship and sustainability.

Though we loved the shoe's design and overall versatile look, we wouldn’t recommend them for spending long hours walking. Though they are comfortable to slip on, we experienced chafing and blisters after walking over 10,000 steps, so they're best for days at the office or occasions where you won't be walking far distances.

After two months of testing, the flats didn't show any signs of wear and tear. If anything, we think they look even better, as the leather has softened a bit and has a slightly worn-in look.

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Leather | Sole: Rubber

Most Comfortable Flats for Narrow Feet

Everlane The Day Glove Flats

Everlane The Italian Leather Day Glove

Everlane

Our Ratings
  • Comfort
    4.5/5
  • Fit
    2.5/5
  • Durability
    5/5
  • Quality
    5/5
  • Support
    5/5
What Stands Out
  • These close-fitting shoes are great for narrow feet.

What Could Be Improved
  • The sizing is not totally intuitive.

These snug-fitting flats are made from supple, supportive leather that hugs your feet like a glove. The silhouette is more casual, but the high-quality materials make this a pretty versatile shoe that you could wear just about anywhere. Plus, this shoe is available in a wide range of colors—in addition to seven standard colors, there's also a rotating selection of limited edition hues.

We found that the cushioned insole provides good support, and the back pull tab is convenient for putting the shoes on. This is a great shoe for people with narrow feet but isn't ideal for those with wide feet or a higher instep. Keep in mind that there are some sizing quirks: Sizes 5–6.5 run large, sizes 7–8.5 run true to size, and sizes 9–11 run small. 

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Leather | Sole: Rubber

Final Verdict

Our overall pick for the most comfortable flats is the Rothy's Square Mary Jane. We love the lightweight material and flexible sole and the fact that the shoes felt comfortable right away. They supported our feet for miles of walking—no blisters in sight. We also appreciated their stylish look, which makes them a great choice for the office, errands, or social events. For those shopping on a budget, opt for the Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flat, which is versatile and available in many colors. 

Our Testing Process

We tested 29 different pairs of flats in real-world conditions over several months. First, we examined each shoe for our first impressions of the materials and construction. Then we tested arch support by bending each shoe in the middle and then trying to wring them out like a dish towel. This helped us see if the arches moved easily, and how flexible the shoe felt. 

Next, we broke in the shoes by wearing them for at least an hour around our homes. We noted our first impressions and what made the shoes comfortable or uncomfortable. We assessed the sturdiness of the soles, the fit, and whether or not it was easy to walk around in the shoes. 

After that, we wore each pair of flats over two months, noting any changes in quality, durability, and comfort. Finally, we evaluated each pair for breathability, support, versatility, traction, and signs of wear and tear. We also noted if the shoes irritated our feet, causing blisters, foot pain, or hot spots. 

A person wears a pair of Naturalizer Samantha Half d'Orsay Flats

Real Simple / Katie Bowler

How to Shop for Comfortable Flats Like a Pro

Arch Support

“Arch support is pivotal in any shoe, including flats,” says Dr. Sharma. “Everyone has a different arch profile, so selecting a shoe that supports your unique arch type (be it high, neutral, or low) is essential. A flat with inadequate arch support can lead to foot fatigue, plantar fasciitis, and other discomforts.”

Flats by nature are, well, flat, so they tend to have less arch support than the typical shoe. Be sure to look for flats that have some support on the bottom, and avoid shoes that have an extra thin sole. To make this process easier, you can look for shoes that have the APMA Seal of Approval, which designates products that promote foot health. If arch support is important to you, we recommend the Vionic Caroll Ballet Flat, which have a removable microfiber-wrapped EVA footbed that provides total comfort.

Material

“Opt for flats made from breathable, natural materials like leather or suede,” says Dr. Abdoo. “These materials allow air circulation, reducing the likelihood of moisture buildup and odors. Additionally, such materials tend to adapt to the shape of your feet, enhancing comfort even during brief periods of use.”

It's worth noting that pretty much all shoes have a break-in period, even ones made of comfortable materials. We found this to be the case in our testing, with many of the shoes feeling slightly tight or too structured at first and then giving way to a more comfortable fit. Going for a naturally malleable material should speed up that process though—we found that to be the case with the Rothy's Square Mary Jane and the Frank Mully Ballet Flat, which are both made of a flexible knit material.

“The makeup of the sole is also important,” says Dr. Sharma. “Dense materials such as wooden soles are poor shock absorbers and can increase stress to the musculoskeletal structure. Rubber and cork materials are preferred sole materials.” All of the shoes on our list have a rubber or leather sole.

Fit

There are a few tips to making sure you have the right fit. “A well-fitting shoe should snugly fit the foot without being too tight,” says Dr. Sharma. “There should be about a thumb’s width of space between the longest toe (which isn’t always the big toe) and the end of the shoe. The heel should fit comfortably against the back of the shoe without slipping out. Also, the widest part of your foot should align with the widest part of the shoe." 

Also, you should consider the shape of the shoe. "Narrow pointed tips can force the digits into an unnatural position and can further degrade existing bunion and hammertoe deformities," says Dr. Sharma. "Rounded or squared tips on the forefoot can help achieve a similar fashion statement as pointed shoes without the added pressure and pain.”

You can still find a pair of comfortable pointed-toe shoes—in particular, we recommend the Vivaia Aria 5° Ballet Flats, which have a knit construction that provides a good amount of give. Another dressy yet comfortable shoe is the Naturalizer Samantha D’Orsay Flat, which has a pointed toe but stretchy sides for better movement.

A heel of the Nisolo Huarache Sandal

Real Simple / Alena Kharlamenko

More Comfortable Flats to Consider

Aerosoles Big Bet Ballet Flat: We liked that this shoe is flexible, lightweight, and cushioned, but we struggled with the lack of arch support. The buckle style works for casual and dressy settings but won’t be great for people who prefer neutral shoe hardware. 

Allbirds Tree Breezers: We loved this shoe's cushy insoles and versatile look. However, we felt like our feet were overheating, even in a chilly office setting—it feels better suited for cold weather wear rather than year-round use. 

Musshoe Pointed Toe Flat: This shoe is comfortable and doesn't pinch or rub. However, we think the soft material around the toe area might show wear and tear over time, and the heel started to bunch after a few wears. We recommend these shoes for short events, but they aren’t ideal for all-day wear. 

A pair of Musshoe Slip-on Pointed Toe Flats

Real Simple / Cathie France

Questions You Might Ask

Are flats better for your feet than other shoes?

“Flats, by design, are not intended for long-term, all-day wear,” says Dr. Abdoo. “These shoes lack the support and cushioning needed for extended use. Prolonged wear of flats can lead to potential issues. I would recommend reserving flats for short-term occasions and opting for more supportive footwear for long-term use to prioritize foot health.”

Still, when you want an elegant, everyday shoe without a high heel or the clunky look of sneakers, comfortable flats can be your go-to. 

How can you make flats more comfortable?

One of the worst parts of wearing new shoes is the break-in period, so you can get a head start by wearing your new shoes around your home for a few hours. Another option to make flats more comfortable is to add supportive insoles

“If the shoe itself does not have a built-in arch support, purchasing a dress orthotic device either over the counter or custom may be essential to prevent foot issues,” Dr. Sharma says.

How do you know when it’s time to replace a pair of flats?

According to Dr. Sharma, it may be time to replace your flats when:

  • You can see noticeable wear on the sole or heel.
  • Any cushioning on the insole has flattened out, so it doesn’t provide support.
  • The shoe has stretched out or lost its shape, so it doesn’t fit securely.
  • You start to experience discomfort or foot pain after wearing the flats.

“No matter how much you love them, once they show signs of significant wear, it’s time for a new pair to ensure optimal foot health,” says Dr. Sharma. 

Take Our Word for It

This article was written by Nina Bahadur, a writer who has spent over a decade covering home, health, commerce, and culture. We tested each shoe in this article in real-world conditions, assessing each pair for comfort, value, fit, support, and quality. We also got expert input from Dr. Shital Sharma, DPM, a board-certified podiatrist with Pinewood Family Care Co., and Dr. David Abdoo, DPM, a podiatrist at ​​Salinas Valley Foot & Ankle. 

What Is Real Simple Selects?

Next to each product on this list, you may have noticed a Real Simple Selects seal of approval. Any product appearing alongside that seal has been vetted by our team—put through tests and graded on its performance to earn a spot on our list. Although we buy most of the products we test, sometimes we do get samples from companies if purchasing a product ourselves isn’t an option. All products go through the same rigorous process, whether they are purchased or sent by the company.

Love our recommendations? Check out more products that have earned the Real Simple Selects, from humidifiers to cordless vacuums.

Was this page helpful?

Related Articles