The Best Celebrity Wrestlers Ever: Pat McAfee, Maria Menounos and More

Andy Kaufman

Kaufman got his wrestling start as the self-proclaimed “Inter-Gender Wrestling Champion of the World” who paid women $1,000 to go one-on-one with him. This led to an iconic feud with Jerry “The King” Lawler, with Kaufman even faking a neck injury from a pile driver given by Lawler to really sell it. Their memorable rivalry spilled over onto Late Night with David Letterman, where Letterman tried to act as a mediator and both men nearly came to blows on air. More than a decade after Kaufman’s death from lung cancer in 1984, Lawler revealed that their entire feud was a work, aka fake, and that they were really good friends.  

“He loved it, loved the business, was so respectful of everybody and everything about the business,” Lawler said of Kaufman.

For his efforts, Kaufman was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame as part of the Class of 2023.  

Snooki

The Jersey Shore star (aka Nicole Elizabeth LaValle) turned heads when she teamed up with John Morrison and Trish Stratus to face Dolph Ziggler and Lay-Cool at WrestleMania 27. A former all-star cheerleader, Snooki showed off her athletic skills in the ring with fun moves like a roundoff back handspring elbow and a cartwheel into a belly splash. Reflecting on the experience during AOL’s BUILD Series, the reality-TV vet revealed that she only had an hour of rehearsal the night before the big event. “They realized I picked up everything quickly because I’m a cheerleader [and] a gymnast,” she said. “They were like, ‘You could do flips? Awesome! Let’s throw this in.’”

Lawrence Taylor

Few celebrities can say they main-evented Wrestlemania like this NFL Hall of Famer. Although he didn’t have much training and was thrown into a match to sell tickets, the former New York Giants linebacker still impressed while competing against Bam Bam Bigelow at WrestleMania 11. His daring move off the top rope alone (watch video above) was a gallant effort that put him above many other celeb fighters.

Logan Paul

The YouTube star trained with both The Miz and Shane Helms before making his in-ring debut at last year’s WrestleMania 38. “He has exceeded the bar every step of the way,” the Miz said. “This kid is on another level.” Paul also impressed fans and Paul Levesque (WWE’s Head of Creative), who put him in the main event of last December’s Crown Jewel pay-per-view against reigning champion Roman Reigns. After holding his own against the company’s top performer, the social media prankster again sent fans into a tizzy at Royal Rumble 2023 thanks to this jaw-dropping mid-air collision with Richocet (watch video above). He’s only getting started, but the celeb-turned-wrestler has already proven that he’s the real deal.

Stephen Amell

The Arrow star showed off stellar moves, including a heroic leap from the top rope, while teaming up with Neville to face Stardust (aka Cody Rhodes) and King Barrett at SummerSlam 2015. Amell returned to the ring in 2017, this time teaming up with the Rhodes’ Bullet Club to face SoCal Uncensored and Flip Gordon at Ring of Honor: Survival of the Fittest (where he put a man through a table!).

He made his singles match debut in 2019 at ROH’s All In, holding his own against legendary wrestler Christopher Daniels. After sustaining a fractured hip from that bout — forcing him to email Arrow EPs Greg Berlanti, Beth Schwartz and Marc Guggenheim ahead of a stunt-heavy Season 7 episode — he vowed to hang up his wrestling boots until the show ended. (Note: Arrow’s series finale aired in January 2020.)

Amell most recently starred as Jack Spade in the wrestling drama Heels, which was cancelled after two seasons in September.  

Dennis Rodman

Rodman has accomplished many things, including five NBA championship wins and a pretty cool WCW stint. Making his debut on the March 10, 1997 edition of Nitro, he was inducted into the NWO after siding Hollywood Hulk Hogan. He went on to make several more appearances, even skipping NBA finals practices during the 1997-98 season. He eventually convinced fellow NBA star Karl Malone to join him in a match at the Bash at the Beach pay-per-view in 1998 (watch video above) — Rodman teamed with Hogan to face Malone and Diamond Dallas Page — where they both put up a pretty good fight. While Malone didn’t return ring, Rodman went on to feud with Randy Savage in 1999.

Bad Bunny

The famed recording artist became the top streaming artist on Spotify, made history with the first all-Spanish album to top the Billboard 200 albums chart, won a Grammy, and then lived out his childhood dream of becoming a WWE wrestler. After a few short Raw appearances in 2021 — during which he won the 24/7 title — the musician teamed up with Damien Priest to fight The Miz and John Morrison at WrestleMania 37. He left a huge impression on fans and wrestlers alike with splashy moves throughout the match, like his crowd-pleasing Canadian Destroyer (watch video above).

He’s had plenty more memorable in-ring moments since then, including showing up at Royal Rumble 2022 to eliminate Sheamus. In May 2023, he fought fellow Puerto Rican wrestler Damian Priest in an all-out San Juan Street Fight at the pay-per-view event Backlash, pulling off an impressive win in front of their hometown crowd. 

Mike Tyson

A key part of good wrestling is being believable, and that’s what Mike Tyson excelled at. Sure, he didn’t have the fancy moves like some of the others on this list, but his brawl with Stone Cold Steve Austin (watch video above) on a 1998 episode of Monday Night Raw felt like a real fight and remains one of the most iconic moments in WWE history. He even turned on Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 14, and was inducted into WWE’s Hall of Fame in 2012. The boxer most recently returned to wrestling in 2020, to feud with Chris Jericho on AEW: Dynamite.

Mr. T

The first WrestleMania was a huge risk for Vince McMahon, and it proved to be wildly successful, partly because of Mr. T’s involvement. Teaming up with Hulk Hogan in the main against “Rowdy” Roddy Piper and Paul “Mr. Wonderful” Orndorff, the TV and film star proved to be just as captivating in the ring with seamless moves, including back-to-back body slams. He spent the next year building up an iconic feud with Piper that peaked with a highly anticipated boxing match at WrestleMania 2. His WWE legacy was cemented in 2014, when he was inducted into the Hall of Fame.

David Arquette

Arquette’s short-lived WCW Championship reign in 2000 is considered one of the worst moments in professional wrestling, but the issue was never his in-ring talent. The actor trained with wrestlers Chris Kanyon, Diamond Dallas Page and Shane Helms (aka WWE’s The Hurricane) for his starring role in the 2000 film Ready to Rumble, and learned to be a decent wrestler. (He even took a mean bump through a table from Randy Orton on a 2010 episode on Monday Night Raw.)

Still, Arquette’s sullied wrestling reputation followed him for years, and he returned to the ring in 2018 to prove his naysayers wrong — a journey documented in the 2020 film You Cannot Kill David Arquette. Although his brutal deathmatch against Nick Gage was horrific (and nearly cost him his life), his efforts on the indie circuit, including a well-executed match against AEW’s Jungle Boy (watch video above), deserves major props.

Maria Menounos

Known for her on-air work on shows like Extra and Access Hollywood, Menounos made her WWE debut in 2009 as a guest host for Raw alongside fellow TV host Nancy O’Dell. That night, she teamed with Kelly Kelly and Gail Kim to face Beth Phoenix, Rosa Mendes and Alicia Fox in a six-woman tag team match.

She returned to the ring in 2011 for WWE’s annual Tribute to the Troops special, teaming up with Alicia Fox, Eve Torres, and Kelly Kelly to face Beth Phoenix, Natalya and Brie and Nikki of the Bella Twins. This reignited Menounos’ rivalry with Phoenix, leading to a match at WrestleMania 28. Despite sustaining two cracked ribs during Dancing with the Stars rehearsals, she still stepped in the ring with Kelly Kelly to take on Beth Phoenix and Eve Torres — ultimately getting the pin on Phoenix.

Menounos hit the squared circle once more at SummerSlam 2013, joining forces with Natalya to fight Brie Bella and Eva Marie in tag team competition.

Pat McAfee

A former NFL punter-turned-sports analyst with innate athletic ability, it’s easy to see why he’s been such a welcome addition to the WWE.

He made his wrestling debut in 2009 — just before being drafted into the NFL— fighting WarPig in singles competition at an IWA East Coast show.

McAfee’s professional football career ended in 2017, and he h made first WWE appearance in 2018, interfering in Adam Cole’s match against Aleister Blac during an NXT show in Indianaopolis (the home of his former NFL team, the Indianapolis Colts). He later signed with WWE as a pre-show analyst for NXT as well as color commentator for SmackDown.

Building up a notable fued with Adam Cole, his first WWE match took place at NXT TakeOver XXX in 2020, where he lost to Cole in singles competition. Since then, McAfee has made various in-ring appearances and impressed with stellar moves, like a stupendous Superplex on Austin Theory at WrestleMania 38.

Adam Cole, speaking on McAfee’s in-ring success for the Inside the Ropes podcast, shared that he “knew [McAfee] was going to do really well” but was “so happy to see that he exceeded everyone’s expectations because I think at this point, he’s proven that he’s darn good, especially for his experience level.”